News 3 Now ·  Desktop WX ·  Contact ·  Site Map
Home  ·   News  ·   Weather  ·   Sports  ·   Features  ·   Business  ·   Morning Show  ·   The Buzz  ·   Eye on You (Your Photos & Videos)  ·   KBTX Cares
At the Movies · Eat.Stay.Play. · Contest · Calendar · Lottery · Blogs · Inside KBTX · Job Search · Obituaries · CW Texas · CBS · Digital TV · Gas Prices
SpeakOut Poll
Are you watching the Olympics in high definition?

Yes
No
I'm not watching the Olympics
I don't have high definition


Community Links
Convicted Murderer Receives Light Sentence Save Email Print
Posted: 2:42 PM May 9, 2008
Last Updated: 11:32 PM May 9, 2008
Reporter: Meredith Stancik
Email Address: stancik@kbtx.com

A | A | A

He was convicted of beating his neighbor to death with a shotgun that wouldn't fire, but on Friday, Lee Hamilton was made a free man.

A Brazos County jury found the 53-year-old guilty of murder Thursday, and one day later, it sentenced Hamilton to 10 years probation.

The jury punished Hamilton to ten years at the Texas Department of Criminal Justice, but decided that the prison sentence should be probated. Hamilton does not have to pay a fine.

"We are pleased that the jury made the right decision in convicting this defendant of murder," Assistant District Attorney Cory Crenshaw said. "Obviously, we feel that violence of this sort should not result in probation, but we respect that difficult decision the jury had to make. We plan to ask Judge Smith to assess both jail time and in custody drug rehabilitation to ensure the defendant is ready for society upon his release back onto the streets of our community."

The judge reset the case for three weeks to determine the conditions of probation should be assessed.

Hamilton escaped conviction in March, when a jury failed to reach a verdict. He could have received a life sentence for the crime.

More Stories
Heavy Rainfall Drenches Texas

TX-TF1 Deployed to Flooded North Texas

News 3 Investigates High B/CS Gas Prices

Bremond Receives Much Needed Rain

Pain at the Pump Worse in B/CS?

A First Glimpse at Reveille VIII

Relatives Call Jacominis' Death A Tragic Loss

4-H Fundraiser Takes the Cake

Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
Email will not be displayed on site. For station contact purpose only.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: Come one' Come all. on May 14, 2008 at 08:56 AM
Thats right, if you would like to get off without punishment for murdering someone-lure them to the Brazos Co. you can actually get away with it! I agree with all of the other posters that believe these idiot jurors should have this murderer for their neighbor and see if they feel that he is no threat to themselves or loved ones....Oh yea' like that will happen.. I guess we can now count on people from Houston,etc. to be moving to our community as they know there is NO judicial system in BCS. Thanks for sending the message Jurors..

Posted by: Richard on May 14, 2008 at 08:48 AM
If you have never sat on a jury or selection process then you don't know that you have throw out morality and religious values. These jurors have to follow guidelines that are outside common sense. Give these jurors a break they did what they HAD to do, not what they wanted to do. Tough to be juror, be thankful that they stayed for the long haul and not find reasons to get out(like many do)and leave it to some other outstanding, concerned, free to vote, citizen of our community.

Posted by: joy Location: bryan on May 13, 2008 at 04:12 PM
HEY HEY HEY I HAVE TO GO ALONG WTH THE JURY AND AS FOR MR, HAMILYON LET ME TELL YOU THE MAN DID NOT KILL HIMIF YOU DO NOT KNOW THE TRUTH SHUT IT UP !!!!!!! IF YOU WERE NOT THERE SHUT UP AND LEAVE LEE ALONG

Posted by: Anonymous Location: Liberal minds at work on May 13, 2008 at 01:14 PM
Mary you may be right. Stupid people may be dangerous in large number. Judge not. I need to make a judgement about a election. Do we need This jury voting again? Does a guilt dog bark loudest? It goes against some of their advise to make a judgement. ONLY LIBERALS NEED TO VOTE. SEE Liberals KNOW WHAT IS BEST FOR ALL OF US. Remember Do not do what I do. Just do what I say. Judge not Mary.

Posted by: big bills again Location: free murder town USA on May 13, 2008 at 07:16 AM
ATTENTION ALL CRIMINALS!! Bryan Texas is having a blue light special on murder. Only 10 yrs probation for murder!! Bring a friend, or heck, bring your enemies from out of town to bryan. Then you can kill them here and get away with a wrist slap!! THIS MAN TOOK A HUMAN SOUL!! PERIOD!! SHAME ON THE COURTS,THE JURY AND OUR COMMUNITY!!

Posted by: Anonymous on May 12, 2008 at 04:18 PM
That's pretty good, john. I sometimes wonder myself what the right thing to do would be. I certainly don't know the whole situation here and probably never will but I also understand everyone's outrage over the sentence he was given. Hhmmm.....

Posted by: Anonymous on May 12, 2008 at 03:08 PM
"Who said stupid people are not dangerous in large numbers." Obviously not us, given the number of you posting here based on rumor and innuendo without knowing all the REAL facts that we on the jury do.

Posted by: Anonymous Location: Navasota on May 12, 2008 at 03:06 PM
A great defense. I think I will do some drugs and get arrested many times. So I if I kill a bad person. I will get probation. Sick family member needed please. I am to ill for jail from Drugs and drinking, but I can take care of one or two sick persons. I am also very trustworthy and dependable on Drugs and drink. MY past arrest were just bad days for me. I will not fail under the stress of my addiction and pressure of taking care of the ill. All I need is for the Police to go away and the DA to stop wasting time when he could prosecute a bad person. Great defense for a Story book.

Posted by: Cerena Location: College Staion on May 12, 2008 at 02:16 PM
Way to go, lets show the world that in Bryan and College Staion that you can be convicted of murder or child rape and only get probation. I don't know about the rest of you but thus sure makes me feel safer

Posted by: john Location: college station on May 12, 2008 at 12:26 PM
>>>What about a Eye for a Eye forgot this one?<<< An eye for an eye means the whole world goes blind. >>>>> It was ruled a murder not a accident. <<<<< Correct, apparently (based on what jurors have said) because the DA would not allow them to consider negligent homicide, probably based on the man's prior record. >>>>>After all Christ was calling a person a hipocrite that was not wise enough to make a judgement.<<<< I believe that concerning his own murderers, he also said "Father forgive them, they know not what they do".

Posted by: Mary Location: Hearne on May 12, 2008 at 12:12 PM
Juries have twelve people don't they? Who said stupid people are not dangerous in large numbers.

Posted by: Hay Bills Location: Bryan on May 12, 2008 at 12:05 PM
Now everyone put away the guns. You have to have a long arrest record and years of drug,alcohol abuse,assaults unlawful possession of weapons and Bad health do to the above. Now you can get probation. BILL

Posted by: Juror - first trial Location: Bryan on May 12, 2008 at 11:43 AM
PROBATION? SHOCKING! This blows my mind! I thought justice had been served! I am dumbfounded!! Yes, one blow did kill Jordon, but Hamilton went inside the home, got a gun and went back outside and literally waited in the dark to ambush Jordan. His size? Yes he appears small and thin in the picture seen in the media, a true reflection of a constant diet of drugs and alcohol! Mr. Hamilton looks quite differently now after WE have been feeding him for the past 11 months! If this was even the remotest act of self-defense, there would have been some sort of scuffle which there was none. If a person weighing more then 200 pounds was coming at me I can guarantee you BOTH of us would have gone down to the ground. Jordan had time when the gun didn't go off to lunge at Hamilton, this didn't happen! It was pre-mediated murder! And now a MURDERER walks OUR streets! So, those of you on the second jury- would you really feel safe with him living next door? I SURE WOULDN'T!

Posted by: JurorTest on May 12, 2008 at 07:42 AM
One more question that you missed, anonymous: If the DA or you on the jury "pick a truth that works" to convict someone for something that they didn't do, you can still call it justice...true or false.

Posted by: bills Location: bryan on May 12, 2008 at 07:27 AM
Cool, now days only 10 yrs probation for murder. I can think of a few people who would be worth it!!!

Posted by: Anonymous on May 11, 2008 at 09:47 PM
What about a Eye for a Eye forgot this one? It was ruled a murder not a accident. Did I miss understand the death penalty is needed based on the bible. Did King James not cover probation. Sounds like a bad judgment happened . After all Christ was calling a person a hipocrite that was not wise enough to make a judgement.

Posted by: Juror's Neighbor Location: Bryan on May 11, 2008 at 07:55 PM
I was not on the jury but my neighbor was - Mr. Hamilton may have had drug and alcohol problems over the years, but it seems that I can't find anywhere in the media that he is a small man who has had a stroke and is partially paralyzed. The man he killed was well over 200 pounds and was not an angel by any means either. Mr. Hamilton has been paroled to go home and take care of his ailing mother and a sister with CP. What the story didn't say was that he HAS to leave Bryan and he has to complete drug and alcohol rehab. The bible says judge not lest ye be judged. I just think there are too many people commenting here that don't realize they are living in glass houses. To the jury -- thank you for not shirking your civic duty and finding some lame excuse to get out of jury duty.

Posted by: Mike Location: Bryan on May 11, 2008 at 02:27 AM
My last comment! Juror< maybe the county should fix his gun,pay for his crack & booze & relocate him to your neighborhood! For Gods Sake WAKE UP PEOPLE!

Posted by: Bill Location: CS on May 10, 2008 at 04:55 PM
We do not need to judge. I thought the US legal system was based on British common law. Judgement of the people was the basis for having elected judges and prosecutor's ,open court room, and all crimes are against the people, and the people had a right to make judgement on the legal system,courts and make changes. Did it change to a closed court system with government appointed judges prosecutors and a closed jury system and the people have we nothing to say about judgement and conduct of the system. Is this communism and liberalism systems we have now? Do Liberals know what best for all? Please do not make any Judgement, put away the voters card the government is now in charge. No judgment needed by the people.

Posted by: john Location: college station on May 10, 2008 at 03:56 PM
>>>>Does it matter where or how the man was killed?<<<< Yes it does; as the jurors said, manslaughter (a killing that was not intended) was probably the appropriate verdict, but that choice wasn't given them by the system. >>>> Ever heard of dialing 911 or was the phone beaten first?<<<< If an attack is going to be over in under a minute, the 5 to 20 minute response time required for the police in even the best days isn't going to do much good; I'm disinclined to try second guessing the "men on the ground". As with the Bell case in New York, those 12 people heard a lot of facts that we didn't and were showed that a lot of what WE heard in the press was wrong...

Posted by: James Location: Bryan on May 10, 2008 at 02:04 PM
I do not know anything about what happened, nor do I know the circumstances surrounding this case. I was not in the courtroom and I was not asked to judge this crime. But I have sat on other juries. I have to believe that what this jury decided was what was best. Who are we to judge these people? I know that very few people answer their jury summons when they come in the mail. I have a neighbor that would rather be fined than go to a jury summons. These people went when asked, was selected (I'm sure they didn't jump up and down begging to be put on this jury) and did the job they were asked to do. So, if any of you that are criticizing are ones that don't answer your jury summons, then you need to not comment. The rest of you, it is not our place to criticize this jury..next time you may be asked to do the same. And to the person who was on the last jury for this case, at least this jury made a decision. Think about it.

Posted by: To Mike on May 10, 2008 at 01:17 PM
There was no phone. The person calling 911 had to go around the corner to do it.

Posted by: Anonymous Location: JUROR TEST NEEDED IN Brazos County on May 10, 2008 at 12:38 PM
How about a future Juror IQ TEST. How many times does a person need to be arrested for assaults and drug related charges and PI. and LET GO to make a Brazos County safe. More than 16x or Less? Drugs and Liquor when abused have nothing to do with crime and have been shown to make an area safe and assaults go down? TRUE or False? A person is not a threat to community because you have not been assaulted or had a family member hurt, just happens to other people. True or false? If you put person on the street with long arrest records, crime will go down and you will save Tax payer money from future arrest cost. True or false? An elected DA with 20yrs of work experience does not know who criminals are and likes to waste money and time. True or False?

Posted by: Mike Location: Bryan on May 10, 2008 at 04:47 AM
Juror. Does it matter where or how the man was killed?! A human life was taken! Ever heard of dialing 911 or was the phone beaten first? Why do you keep posting comments,are we feeling GUILTY!

Posted by: blah on May 10, 2008 at 02:27 AM
BRAZOS COUNTY COURT HOUSE N EVERYONE THAT WORKS IN THE COURT HOUSE SUCKS!!

Posted by: another juror on May 10, 2008 at 12:00 AM
I too sat on this jury. It was a very difficult trial, and a very difficult 5 days. Do you not think that we didn't think about the community? All 12 of us live in this community. Do you think that we would allow a dangerous man to walk the same streets as our children? Mr. Hamilton is not a threat to anyone anymore. Mr. Jordan was killed by a SINGLE blow to the head, it just happened to be in the right place on the head to cause death. Do not judge this jury unless you know all of the facts of this case. And Jason, I hope you do find a place where there are no criminals, but please let us know where that is.

Posted by: Paul Location: CS on May 9, 2008 at 11:37 PM
Are you kidding me? Probation for murder? I got an idea, make it a condition of his probation that this guy move in next door to the judge or one of these jurors. Perhaps then they will lock him up and get him off our streets. My heart goes out to the victim's family.

Posted by: Lost Location: In Texas on May 9, 2008 at 11:19 PM
KBTX, where is the rest of the story? I must have missed the first go around. Could you add a few more details to the story before everyone gets in a panic? I figure the jury would have been harder on him had it been in cold blood or planned, but with no details we have no way of knowing what happened. Heck 10 years probation could have been too much by what Juror is saying.

Posted by: X Location: z on May 9, 2008 at 10:15 PM
Put yourself in his place. What would you do if somoneone says if you don't kill me then I'm going to kill you. Would you fight back or would you just let them kill you.

Posted by: Juror on May 9, 2008 at 07:54 PM
I also sat on this jury. Like it was said, this was a very difficult case and a very difficult 5 days. Do you not believe that we did not take into consideration the community? This man is not a threat to anyone. The single blow to the head happened to a lucky blow. We were not given the option of manslaughter, which in my opinion this is clearly a perfect case for that. I do raise a family in this community, and I do not think having Mr. Hamilton out on probation threatens the safety of my family. You have no right to judge our decision.

Posted by: Shawn Location: B/CS on May 9, 2008 at 07:47 PM
Juror-If I or one of my loved ones are murdered, please turn in your notice saying that you will be unable to be a juror for the trial. Probation, what a joke......

Posted by: Chuck Location: Bryan on May 9, 2008 at 07:20 PM
I hope you people that claim to be on the jury aren't allowed to vote.

Posted by: Tyronda Turner Patton Location: Bryan on May 9, 2008 at 06:05 PM
God Bless You no matter what people say or think it all abids by gods say so and god never falls a good man!!!KEEP YOUR HEAD UP AND STAY AWAY FROM YOUR DOWN FALLS THIS IS A WAKE UP CALL FOR YOU GOD WANTS YOUR ATTENTION AND PLEASE LISTEN!!!!!!!

Posted by: Anonymous Location: Bryan on May 9, 2008 at 06:00 PM
WOW! A person with a long history of drug and alcohol abuse is not a threat to anyone. Also a history of arrest with violence. Learned something new.

Posted by: sad day Location: B/CS on May 9, 2008 at 05:56 PM
Juror, You can try to justify your actions all you want. The fact is Hamilton took the life of another human. I supose that his life was only worth probation. I hope Hamilton moves in next to you and then we'll see if you still feel that he is no threat to anyone. If someone killed one of your family members would you still agree that probation is appropriate? I suppose that since the gun wouldn't fire and it only took him one hit to kill him then that somehow justifies his actions. He is just as dead as he would be if he were shot or if it would have taken several blows. I expect that we will now have more of these trials because people will see that the punishment for killing someone is nothing more than probation. Hopefully the next time we have a trial like this the jury will deliver a punishment that fits the taking of human life.

Posted by: Anonymous Location: BRYAN on May 9, 2008 at 05:36 PM
Is this the same Lee Hamilton posted on the Brazos county web records page? Arrested in Jailed 17x In Bryan only. For assaults, Drug related charges, assaults on family, Unlawful carrying of weapons, PI and now murder. It most be someone different. I will sleep good in Bryan thinking he is not danger to anyone as the juror said. It most be a different person of the same age, On the sheriff web booking reports.

Posted by: Juror Location: Bryan on May 9, 2008 at 05:26 PM
Okay I was on the first jury and I heard everything that went on. Mr. Hamilton should not have recieved probation! The second jury I guess thought was just some man that was trying to protect himself, but that was not the case. He tried to shoot the man and when the gun didnt go off he hit him in the head and killed him. Really he should have recieved jail time.

Posted by: Anonymous on May 9, 2008 at 04:40 PM
He sure was a threat to the man he killed haha idiot

Posted by: Duh Location: Here on May 9, 2008 at 04:24 PM
Well well. I guess he'll join the O J Club! I'm from Houston & this city is getting more & more like Houston!,except in Houston Hamilton would be OFF the streets!

Posted by: dj Location: Brenham on May 9, 2008 at 04:19 PM
Though I was not a juror I have been a juror in this type of case before, and yes it is very hard, but mr. juror you are not the police that will have to deal with this man again, obviously you alol did not put consider the law enforcenment officers that have to deal with these type people again, and again, and I say this because it will happen, mark my word, mr. juror, this is not the last this man has seen of the criminal justice system. I guess it will have to be up to the judge to give him some jail time since you did not have the courage to.

Posted by: Juror on May 9, 2008 at 04:03 PM
The man that was killed was not Mr. Hamilton's neighbor, he was visiting Mr. Hamilton's neighbor and was on Mr. Hamilton's property. Also he in no way beat him to death. It was a single blow that happened to be in a bad place. Just to clarify further.

Posted by: Juror on May 9, 2008 at 03:50 PM
Having sat on this jury, I know what happened and know that the sentence we gave to this man was more than fair. Unless you know the circumstances, you have no right to judge our decisions or the guilt of Mr. Hamilton. If you are interested in making comments on this article you should be interested enough to learn what actually happened and know that what we did in that jury room was right. Sitting through this trial was the hardest 5 days of my life and extremely emotional to see what Mr. Hamilton had been put through and faced with the night of the incident. Were it not for the exact letter of the law. If this case was easy to determine why do you think the first jury couldn't decide and why do you think it took us a whole day of deliberations?!? Study up on the facts and know that Mr Hamilton is in no way a threat to anyone.

Posted by: bob on May 9, 2008 at 03:40 PM
brazos county should be proud, this is pathetic!!

Posted by: Mason Location: Bryan on May 9, 2008 at 03:37 PM
Oh and hey Jason, the judge has nothing to do with the verdict or the punishment. Nice try though. Also, you fail to realize that Brazos County is one of the states strictest when it comes to punishment of crimes. Get your facts straight bud, go ahead and move somewhere with a false sense of security

Posted by: Mr. Kirk Location: College Station on May 9, 2008 at 03:33 PM
Good for Mr. Hamilton, I love it

Posted by: kris Location: cs on May 9, 2008 at 03:27 PM
oh ok he got probation for murder why not he only beat someone to death in a very cold hearted way why NOT probation!! OK, Really what is wrong with our JUDGEMENT PEOPLE!!!

Posted by: Jason Location: Bryan on May 9, 2008 at 03:09 PM
Nice! Way to go Brazos County! I feel real safe in my bed now that this has taken place. Nice to see nobody cares about punishing a criminal in this county. This is icing on the cake considering the recent revelations on repeat offenders in this county. No wonder Bryan is becoming more and more unsafe. And to think I was considering staying in this area once I graduated from A&M. I know now that it is no longer an option to stay here and raise a family when thing like this are allowed to happen. The jury and judge should be ashamed of themselves and when this person kills again it will be their fault and once again nothing will change. These things are the exact reason nobody fears the judicial system anymore. Beat someone to death and get probation!

Posted by: Anonymous on May 9, 2008 at 02:55 PM
Man, I sure would like to know more details on this case. I won't pre-judge because I don't know what happened, but it's such a light sentence and for the jury to have problems deciding....What really happened? Does anyone know?

KBTX.com Video Player
AP Video
Digital TV