News 3 Now ·  Desktop WX ·  Contact ·  Site Map
Home  ·   News  ·   Weather  ·   Sports  ·   Features  ·   Business  ·   Morning Show  ·   The Buzz  ·   Eye on You (Your Photos & Videos)  ·   KBTX Cares  ·   Green
At the Movies · Eat.Stay.Play. · Contest · Calendar · Lottery · Blogs · Inside KBTX · Job Search · Obituaries · CW Texas · CBS · Digital TV · Pump Patrol
SpeakOut Poll
If Senator Kay Bailey Hutchison runs for Texas Governor, would you vote for her? (Click here to learn more and voice your opinion)

Yes
No


Community Links
"Noose" Controversy: Racism vs Office Horseplay in Caldwell Save Email Print
Posted: 6:20 PM Sep 2, 2008
Last Updated: 2:23 AM Sep 3, 2008
Reporter: Kristen Ross
Email Address: ross@kbtx.com

A | A | A

Is it a case of racial discrimination, or an office joke?

A local man says he received the ultimate form of discrimination in the workplace, a "noose" sitting on his desk.

However, the controversy revolves around whether it was actually a "noose" or just a "rope".

It's been nothing but tears of sadness for Linda Eglan, after her husband Joseph found a roughed up piece of rope, knotted into something that looked more like a hangman's noose on his office desk just a few weeks ago.

"It's a noose, it's the thing our forefathers and ancestors were hung with," Linda Eglan said "There's nothing funny about that."

"I was very upset, I was mad," Joseph Eglan said.

Joseph works for Big Creek Construction in Caldwell, and says upper management came out to conduct their own investigation into what happened just a couple of weeks ago. However, it's how they're handling that investigation that has Joseph concerned.

"He called it a rope several times, matter of fact he said it was a rope," Joseph said."I said noose, he said rope, I said noose. I said sir if you're not going to call it what it is, a noose, not a piece of rope this conversation is over."

The company wrote Joseph a letter, in it time and time again using the word "rope" and not the word "noose".

They also added that no one at Joseph's shop is aware of any racial issues, jokes, insults, or discrimination of any kind.

However, to Linda that's exactly what the noose represents.

"Hatred.......hatred, and I'm so angry," Linda said.

We contacted the Big Creek Construction Company's main office in Waco, but they declined to comment.

So we decided to stop by the construction company in Caldwell, and see what they had to say about the Eglan's story.

"I think it's all been blown way out of proportion it really has," a manager said.

The Eglan's say the noose encounter is being passed off as joke, and that everyone at the construction company is acting like they're just making a big deal out of nothing.

"It's been like brother J why did you go to the supervisor we could have handled this," Joseph said. "That's exactly the reaction I've gotten from this, more like I did something wrong."

"It's like we are the ones that have committed the crime, and we haven't. That's just ridiculous," Linda said. "This is 2008, not '68, or '58, we've lived this in our teenage years."

And it's something they hope they never have to relive again.

The Eglan's say one of the employees involved in the noose incident has been given a raise, and that no other action has been taken at the work site.

They since have filed their own grievance with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, and have just received a letter back from the EEOC stating their charge is eligible for mediation.

More Stories
Red-Light Fight

Noriega Cabinet Nominee

Santa's Wonderland Goes Green to Save Green

Toy Drive Brings Smile to Brazos Valley Family

Miniature Firehouse to be Auctioned at Charity Event

Hundreds Enjoy Bryan Holiday Magic Event

Pres. Bush Buys Dallas Home

Hutchison Takes First Step Toward Run For Governor

Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
Email will not be displayed on site. For station contact purpose only.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: Here we go again! Location: BV on Sep 21, 2008 at 10:57 PM
Has anyone inquired about his previous employers? Because he sued an employer about several years ago over something similar in where he turned it all around to be racial discrimination. He is not racially discriminated! He is the one who is racist and that is how he takes advantage of opportunity when he sees it and cashes in. This guy knows what he is doing. Big Creek Construction and EEOC need to wise up to this. When does it stop? This is fraud, again!Plain and simple.

Posted by: Cleus Location: Cainhoy on Sep 10, 2008 at 06:10 PM
Can I file a lawsuit using EEOC because *each* of my shoes somehow ends up with a pair 'nooses' dangling from them each time I tie them?? Is that not the new "PC" approach: that perception is more important than reality??

Posted by: jesse jasckon Location: washingotn dc on Sep 10, 2008 at 03:28 PM
this be a outrage. this here man was claerly discriminated aginst by his white supremecist employers. how much longer must my peoples be getting hated on by the white man in this country. we demand us some justice up in here fo sheezy.

Posted by: Veruca Salt Location: Wixon Valley on Sep 10, 2008 at 08:59 AM
Nooses! Neeses! I want my noose to lay gold eggs for Easter! I want the works I want the whole works Presents and prizes and sweets and surprises Of all shapes and sizes And now Don't care how I want it now

Posted by: R.C. Location: Bryan on Sep 9, 2008 at 03:11 PM
Watch out. If this guy thinks things aren't going his way, prepare for reports of nooses in trees on his property, white hooded figures at night and "alleged" property damages and "threats" We all know his type. Ever since the Jena 666, people have been claiming lawsuits over nooses. This guy knows. He read about it in the Eagle last year.......

Posted by: MyOpinion Location: college station on Sep 6, 2008 at 06:57 PM
Cleus i think you are on the wrong site. This isnt about rap music. People please stop bringing your personal problems on here.If you feel you have issues with rap music then get off here and do something like Eglan did.Now my opinion on here is im a little undecided on this noose thing. But my ? is if Mr. Eglan thought it was a noose and reported it. Why at that time did the manager not leave the noose/rope there and find out who left it there. If they found the person then ask him what was it meant to be. If no one came forward then i would be suspicious because if it was a noose im sure no one would come forward. Then, if it was a rope there would of been a probability that some would of came forward and said "i had it but it wasnt a noose" i was using it to tie whatever.No one is going to own up to a noose.I think we all know that.A rope though it would of been good chances some one would of admitted.I also want to say it evident people have issues but dont let this ruin our town.

Posted by: Looking on Sep 6, 2008 at 11:48 AM
To the person who said something about rap music being played at their job. You do have a right to have a work enviroment that is safe , that you don't feel threatened. Trust me, you do have a case. That is why most jobs don't allow any music except for elevator music, Tv's in public places are either on The Weather Channel or CNN or Fox News. This is to keep people from being offended. The EEOC will not appreciate him going public in the beginning phase of his claim. Also, I know the noose/rope was a bad thing to happen. Yet, does he have anymore proof that there was racism at his job. Trust me, you need alot of documentation. Because noone on the job will support you. So, you have to have dates things happened, papers showing these things. It's a long process.

Posted by: Bryan Location: Bryan on Sep 6, 2008 at 08:05 AM
Hey Woody, your the worst poster on these blogs, you cry like a little tit about everyone ELSE being racist when your the first person to dog the city of Bryan about their black criminals. and you call someone else fake? Your a pathetic little loser.

Posted by: insight Location: bryan on Sep 6, 2008 at 01:41 AM
Why is this "just browsing" character keep saying what he has heard second hand and then makes a judgement on this.Why dont you get your facts straight then come back.Oops! you cant get them straight you wasnt there.This man was probably offended.You and a lot of other people on here is making it like he is the criminal. So far as we all know he is the victim. Then you have people on here so concerned about him having a desk or not.Thats not important.Thats why this world is so screwed up today because of people like the ones on here. You worry about things thats not important.The hell with the desk,and about people needing handouts. We've all received handouts one time or another in our life.If you havent yet,you will one day take my word.Lets focus on the major issue and that is was thing man victimized with the noose(rope) or not.Only him and the people that work there really know.We dont know if there was issues or not before this even happened.

Posted by: r Location: mad county on Sep 6, 2008 at 01:07 AM
oops must be on wrong blog since dont c any one bashing madison county sheriff dept. but they were probably somehow to blame for this incident anyway

Posted by: ghostwriter Location: college station on Sep 6, 2008 at 12:12 AM
Now, see i suggested everyone stop posting about this a find something better to do, but nooo.Now here goes someone else with this he said she said.Then tells people to get their facts straight.You said someone told you so that means you dont know the true facts either.Only that man really knows and whoever put that nonsense on the desk if it was a noose. Everybody should quit being so judgemental of others. I guarantee everybody on here posting their crazy thoughts has issues.None of you are perfect.So stop trying to make up your own version of what happened.Can someone honestly say if they were in his shoes they would just walk it off.If at anytime someone feel they have been mistreated they tell manager/supervisor so dont judge this man. just pray for him and hope everything is solved. Try to be human for once and not animals, my GOD!.Please dont let KBTX divide our town any worse than what it is with this nonsense.I hope the negative people arent christians.

Posted by: Cleus Location: Cainhoy on Sep 5, 2008 at 11:40 PM
Has not anyone noted that a substantial percentage of these incidents have been proven to be done by the alleged aggrieved party. Attention-seeking or just wrangling for a chunk of $$ in compensation for a 'hostile work environment'?? Can I file an EEOC lawsuit because I am forced to listen to rap music at my workplace? Rap music makes me feel threatened and uncomfortable...where is my 'greenback poultice' for this injustice as I feel that I am in a 'hostile work place"? Failing monetary recompense, can I just use the same language when addressing the minority co-workers who tune the radio to stations broadcasting this crap?

Posted by: just browsing Location: nz, tx on Sep 5, 2008 at 10:48 PM
the whole story should be reported. this man came to the news so that he could be put on there. i read in one post below and heard from someone else that he doesnt have a desk at that office. its a construction office how many people do you really think have a desk there. this man is just trying to get his 15 min of fame and see waht he can get out of the company. go check his record, i have also heard this isnt his first time to make racial accusations. for the comment about halliburton bringing all their "trash" to caldwell, quite a few of the folks that work for halliburton dont even live in caldwell so maybe you should get your facts straight. i guess from your comment i am just white trailer park trash since i have family members that work there even though they drive and hour to get to caldwell to work every day and then spend their money in YOUR town so that it helps your tax revenue. the race card is played entirely too much but you dont see me hollering b/c someone offends me

Posted by: Looking on Sep 5, 2008 at 09:33 PM
Really the man should not have broadcast it on the news he was using the EEOC. I know my paper from the EEOC can not be made public. The mediation is the first form you get after they make a charge against the employer. After this you get to go back and forth on rebuttles. So, if the man has not made his paper of what he wants from the company he needs to do it. Personally, I have not notified the news of my EEOC claim. I thought about it, but didn't do it. Mine is not due to racisim though.

Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 5, 2008 at 09:32 PM
I'm white and I don't have hatred for any race, except the stupid race.

Posted by: nonya Location: in town on Sep 5, 2008 at 09:11 PM
Quite a few of you people or maybe even more really need to get evaluated, seriously.Its evident that racism is a serious sickness mentally.Why are the hispanics, chinese and white people ganging up on the blacks.You wonder why blacks complain and have so much hatred for us.Look whats going on here.Im white and i dont think there is any race better than the other. I dont even understand why the hispanics are complaining they're living good over here with all their handouts.I've seen chinese and arab people going into the welfare office.Yes,i've also seen a lot of whites go there also.I've also seen all races with wic.My parents never raised me to be racist.I treat everyone equally and some of you should try it. I get along with all races and i live a stress free life. If you people would stop worrying about other races and how they live you too wouldnt be so stressed out and old looking. Just worry about what you do in life.Why are yall making it your concern about how others live.

Posted by: ghostwriter Location: college station on Sep 5, 2008 at 08:33 PM
Some of you people on here make teachers look bad.I thought comprehension was taught in school.There's also some parents that should be ashame(only some because some parents teach their kids to be racist.)You people dont comprehend to well,do you?Nobody asked you about your hangups.You were asked to comment about one thing and one thing only the noose/rope issue.Come on people,and some of you probably go to or went to blinn and Texas A&M.You have to be more intelligent than this.This dont sound like college educated people.What does any of this has to do with the topic.Why aren't any of you mad at the people that asked you to comment on this.One tv station is helping in dividing this community.I really dont understand why someone will ask this question anyway.Knowing any racial question will bring out the worst in people. Please stop responding to this and find something better to do.

Posted by: Woody Location: College Station on Sep 5, 2008 at 07:08 PM
"Bryan" from Bryan I knew you where fake but don't try to rub it off you racist pig

Posted by: RJ Location: Texas on Sep 5, 2008 at 06:10 PM
To Susie: So you're an American from Europe? Funny, my family was here for 6 generations, had nothing to do with the slave trade or anything close to it and I must be lumped into your very broad brushstroke of false guilt. You, perhaps, are probably the most misinformed person on this forum. And though I may be white and yes, I would want the guy who did this fired. But it makes me even more angry that people like you are use generalizations and stereotypes and half-truths to further divide us. And you're whole point about Americans of Chinese descent is far from truth. If you read your history, or the other half you haven't read yet, you'd see that yes, some corporations bent on profiteering from the Gold Rush brought in immigrants from the Far East and basically treated them like slaves for the gold trade and the transcontinental railroad. Also, remember the Irish indentured servants brought over by the british during colonization? Slavery is not exclusive to one race, its human.

Posted by: Sigh on Sep 5, 2008 at 06:03 PM
Anytime something racist occurs why do people always defend the act by saying blacks are asking for handouts or my favorite "get over slavery!" WTF does that have to do with the cost of peanuts, seriously?! As a black person, I'm not asking for handouts, I don't blame my short comings on slavery, but my own lack of motivation. However, I refuse to tolerate bigotry and hate from anyone black or white. This man regardless of his race has a right to defend himself. No one should be made to feel like they are being bullied or harassed at work, NO ONE!

Posted by: DEAR SUSIE Location: Bryan on Sep 5, 2008 at 04:48 PM
As a matter of FACT, my ancestors nor my family were 'responsible for such atrocities' as 'captur[ing blacks] from their homeland, forced to endure grueling voyages across the sea, and sold into slavery'. You are now applying the same stereotype blanket about which you are complaining. Additionally, I HIGHLY doubt you could find 1 in 10 black people in Bryan, especially those who complain the loudest, that personally know a family member who was a slave (a REAL slave, not just someone forced to work for a living in modern times). This whole 'noose' story is very suspicious and is beginning to look like reverse racism - it HAD to be a noose, it HAD to have been placed by a white person, it HAD to be for him, it HAD to be a racially-motivated hate crime. What if another black employee had needed to tie a box shut and put the 'rope' down, only for this man to stumble upon it and immediately cry racism threats? There are two sides to every story and then there is the truth.

Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 5, 2008 at 04:30 PM
If the rope was made in a way to make a noose, why is it now just a rope?

Posted by: Bryan Location: Bryan on Sep 5, 2008 at 04:26 PM
Susie and Woody must be the same poster.

Posted by: Annym. Location: Bryan on Sep 5, 2008 at 02:46 PM
Michelle: you are obviously ignorant in the worst possible way. It's people like you that give African Americans a reason to resent us. If you havent noticed one of the greatest presidential candidates is BLACK. Dont be so judgmental and prude. Its a disgrace to the American Society.

Posted by: darlin byan texas on Sep 5, 2008 at 02:44 PM
the comment that was made about all black are looking for a handout that's not true because i am black and i work two jobs to support myself and my family but let the truth be known we don't know oneday to the next what card life is going to deal you and if you got a job be thankful for it.that's the only way michelle you are not on welfare is because of your job.so don't know what may happen to you in this lifetime.you telling my race to go back to africa i can't go nowhere i haven't been my family live in america and beside this has nothing to to do with the issue at hand. someone put a noose on this man desk and he should be up set and it shouldn't be allow in the workplace and all of of this should be taken serious, and if just swept under the rug uit will happen again and i would have done the same thang.alot of times the one is saying it's nothing because it hasn't happen to them or their family.my suggestion to the man and his family if you can't get result with the company

Posted by: Susie Location: CS on Sep 5, 2008 at 11:41 AM
To the Chinese American: There is a big difference in Chinese Americans and African Americas. The Chinese were not captured from their homeland, forced to endure grueling voyages across the sea, and sold into slavery. We, the "European americans", were responsible for such atrocities, and owe the generations of African Americans that follow. We don't OWE the Chinese Americans for such crimes. And by the way, who says that African American don't work!! What a racist assertion.

Posted by: Woody Location: College Station on Sep 5, 2008 at 10:16 AM
Michelle and Wa Jo you are the same poster I bet. And if "WO JO" is real this is not a message board on "HAND OUTS" or "Discounts" This guy has nothing to do with that. Read the news and don't take your hatred on this Innocent guy.

Posted by: Colorblindboy Location: Bryan on Sep 5, 2008 at 10:13 AM
Less QQ, more pew pew.

Posted by: Michelle Location: CS on Sep 5, 2008 at 09:26 AM
Way to go Wa Jo!! See it's not just the whites that are tired of all the blacks on welfare and it's not just the whites tired of the blacks sitting around waiting on a handout. Lots of different races have been persecuted over the years, chinese, jews, indians (well they are waiting for a handout too), so please get a job, quit doing drugs, and quit teaching your kids that somebody owes them something, when they should be working to get a better life themselves. Lets see if KBTX will post this, they will post anything anybody says about white people but let them say something about black people and they will reject it. I hope KBTX will be fair and start printing stuff from both sides.

Posted by: Wa Jo Location: Bryan on Sep 5, 2008 at 12:46 AM
To "Woody" I am Chinese American. I am sick and tired of "African American" asking for handout instead of getting job or asking for discount on delivery for stupid reason. Chinese people live underground as slave in US too but work for family not be animal at zoo for handout.

Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 4, 2008 at 11:30 PM
I think that if you know your co-workers you can discern whether or not it was racially an issue or not. I for one wouldn't be putting a rope at anyone's desk and I've been at my job for almost 10 years... that kind of joke just isn't ok regardless of race.

Posted by: Sarah Location: CS on Sep 4, 2008 at 07:10 PM
KBTX. Thanks for the reporting of this. I am glad to see that you are for the people.

Posted by: Dusty Location: Bryan on Sep 4, 2008 at 06:46 PM
It could be worse... He could have been run over by an Caldwell Police Officer. I say he is doing pretty good at that company, he keeps referring to returning to his office. Alot of people dont have an office, just a cubicle.

Posted by: Demetria Location: Bryan on Sep 4, 2008 at 05:34 PM
I can't believe all the sick and twisted comments I have read. In this day and time we as American people should not be making comments about each others race. If this was a joke it was wrong and it should be considered as that. If it had been something done to someone else of another race and they thought that it was wrong it should have been considered wrong also. There are certain things that you do to people that you should think about before you do them. I find it very offensive not just as an African American but as a person. We should all find this something that shouldn't be allowed to happen to anyone not just because the color of their skin, but because they are human.I'm sorry for the people that feel that this was a joke because we are setting a bad example for our children. the persons that was responsible should be terminated! Horseplay should stay at home and so should whatever feelings you have about someone elses race!!! Take the time to think before you act.

Posted by: The Big L Location: Somewhere else on Sep 4, 2008 at 04:51 PM
I used to live in Caldwell, thought it was a nice little town...sounds like things have gone to hell. Guess it all turned out for the best.

Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 4, 2008 at 04:31 PM
To Truth Hurts and Proud American Black... "Got Education?"

Posted by: Woody Location: College Station on Sep 4, 2008 at 04:30 PM
To all African American, Hispanics, Chinese, Japanese and Other. Let these white people post there comments. Don't pay attention to them. This is what they want you to do. Leave the board and let them post there comments to each other and they will realize what they are. They don't realize they are in fact racist. This subject has changed into showing the true colors of people. I am now feeling bad for this guy. Them people hurt his feelings and no one should feel uncomfortable at there work. Do not reply to these devilish people.

Posted by: Kevin Location: Bryan on Sep 4, 2008 at 01:31 PM
Wah! Wah! Wah! My home and place of business were robbed 3 times by black people, I guess they should outlaw black people in public so I am not offended when I see them. (BPD caught them all) Thanks BPD!

Posted by: On Woodys Side Location: College Station on Sep 4, 2008 at 01:10 PM
Anonymous on Sep 3, 2008 at 11:05 PM you just made no sense on your little joke. Who else thinks this is funny? I see about 20 other comments on here with misspelled words. I think its a problem you have with woody. Get a life loser.

Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 4, 2008 at 12:14 PM
If this had been a white person that received the rope, noose, would there be such a BIG DEAL made of it? I dont think so! GET OVER IT!

Posted by: Anonymous Location: Bryan on Sep 4, 2008 at 12:02 PM
Does this gentleman actually know that this was intended for him? If so, then I can understand him being offended,if it was a noose and not just a rope. And if the company can identify who put it there, company actions should be taken and that person or person's owe him an apology. However, I don't know if it offended him before he went home and shared this with his wife. Sounds like he didn't have pain and suffering until she got involved. If I had found something like that on my desk I probably would have moved it and gone on about my work. I am also tired of people playing the "race card". I have to agree, it appears they are looking to make some money out of this. I would certainly have it investigated, but I would not sue over something like this.

Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 4, 2008 at 11:39 AM
Hmmmmm, whats going on here, now I see an article :Man Claiming Discrimination Says No to Mediation:---this doesnt pass the smell test! I have to wonder why if he was so upset by this "noose" as he calls it, why he wont go to mediation??????? I smell a rat here

Posted by: don't be upitty Location: bryan on Sep 4, 2008 at 10:26 AM
Look you need to calm down. You bunch of of fools are getting riled up over nothing.

Posted by: theDoctor Location: Bryan on Sep 4, 2008 at 10:06 AM
Yes Educated I agree with you. Hillbillies of the Brazos Valley UNITE! I guess most of you out there believe that calling a woman babe, or hitting her on the butt on your jobs is not sexual harassment either? People that is why we have laws. It does not have to be offensive to you. For that matter a lot of crimes are not offensive to some people. They call the socio paths.

Posted by: Nobody's Fool on Sep 4, 2008 at 08:18 AM
To Educated White Man: Why are just the white people racist jerks? I've read several mean comments made about white people and yet you had no comment for those. Typical. Can you see why alot of white people have a chip on their shoulders these days? We're made out to be evil and frankly I'm sick and tired of it. I wasn't raised to be prejudiced. I was raised that we are all God's children and should treat each other as such. That it was I now teach my children. I can't help the ones out there who weren't raised that way, but come on, racism is alive in the black community as well and I know first-hand about it. I'm sorry that this man was so offended but these things happen to all races all the time and until we can all treat each other with love and respect, these things are going to continue REGARDLESS OF COLOR.

Posted by: Cynthia Location: Bryan on Sep 4, 2008 at 08:01 AM
If I found a noose on my desk, I do believe I would take it as a threat. Not funny at all.

Posted by: ProudAmericanBlack on Sep 4, 2008 at 07:51 AM
I wasn't their,and probably none of these people commenting was either. The point is no one can decided what offend another person,why all the negative comments from people saying all blacks want is hand outs and he just want money. Blacks are not the only RACE that sue or get Welfare, plenty people that don't deserve or need it get it. I am black and proud and never got welfare on free lunch or WIC,HUD or whatever else people think black people get. My father is 87 and mother is 84, they never got welfare always worked, so stop labeling black people and stick the point at hand, NOOSE or ROPE. Don't play jokes at work,you are their to work. For whomever the Hispanic that said blacks always want a handout, go to HEB and to the WIC office and to St Joseph Hospital or the Health Clinic on Texas Ave to see how many none black people are getting handouts. If people don't want to be label racist, keep your jokes or pranks to friends or family. In the end the truth will come out.

Posted by: Educated white man Location: BCS on Sep 4, 2008 at 07:23 AM
What a bunch of white ,ignorant, racists. It's better to be thought a fool, than open your mouth and remove all doubt. Well, nobody had to open their mouth here to show they're fools. You can tell the idiots on here have never been exposed to other cultures. They have never lived anywhere else, so all they know are their inbred ways. Yee-haw Brazos Valley. The South is gonna rise again. Not a good set of teeth between all of you!

Posted by: TruthHurts Location: college station on Sep 4, 2008 at 12:25 AM
Some of u need 2 stop w/the comments already.Non of u people will never know what he's feeling unless u were in his shoes. If non of u was there 2 actually see what happened or 2 see if it was a noose or not,u shouldnt judge him.Thats a shame some of u has brought up issues other than the noose.To the hispanic that said "most blacks think we owe them something".Get real!Thats the first i heard that.Hispanics dont have anything.They're always looking for handouts.Free food,free health care,etc.For JKO who say "majority of blacks r taking advantage of the system".Can u tell me what survey you read 2 make that statement true.I have seen quite a bit of white people going in2 the welfare office.Some states have more whites on welfare,some states have more blacks,some have more hispanics.I think its about equal if you looked at the big picture.Stop all the racial comments that cont. 2 keep races divided.These neg. comments is what make some of us believe it was a noose.

Posted by: RJ Location: Texas on Sep 4, 2008 at 12:22 AM
Was I there in person to see this-no. I'm only going off the news story and video. What may be a noose may be a rope, whatever. However, is there still racism in the US in 08: hell yes. But as a teacher I see it in every classroom from every student in some form or fashion, no matter skin tone or economic background or whatever. Even in my own family I've seen it. I made a choice not to continue the cycle. However, someone getting a noose is a sick, twisted joke. It is a symbol of death. Yes, it has serious connotations for Americans of african descent. But it is a mechanism of execution that has been used for many generations in multiple places on Earth to multiple people, irregardless of color, status, rank, religion, etc. The guilty party should be fired, easy as that. But to promote racism from the opposite direction, as some previous posters have called (Quanell X & Black Panthers) is just as bad as what has happened. Proof that prejudice knows no limits on skin tone.

Posted by: Hang'em High Location: Centerville on Sep 3, 2008 at 11:14 PM
I thought that Clint Eastwood had a noose around his neck in the movie Hang'em High. I think he is a white person. Also the movie The Good The Bad and the Ugly, he wore a noose, and in the end the Mexican,"the ugly" had a noose shot off his neck by Eastwood. So how is it that a noose makes this a racist thing? Some people will go to any lengths to get money.

Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 3, 2008 at 11:05 PM
On Woody Location: College Station If I found a nose I wouldn't consider it a threat, I would consider it being nosey!!! Ha!Ha!Ha! Learn how to spell before you start making educational comments or at least proofread what you write!!!

Posted by: PAUL Location: SNOOK on Sep 3, 2008 at 09:19 PM
JUST SOMEONE TRYING TO GET SOME MONEY FOR NOTHING. HAVE YOU BEEN THREATEN OR BEATEN. COME ON AND GROW UP.

Posted by: a guy Location: caldwell on Sep 3, 2008 at 09:07 PM
public hangings should be brought back instead of lethal injection. then a noose wouldn't be such a big deal. and just because some guy in caldwell MIGHT be racist doesn't mean the whole city is. you cant pretend that bryan or college station does not have its fair share of racists.

Posted by: Free At Last on Sep 3, 2008 at 08:40 PM
First of all per webster, a noose is a loop in a rope,so call it rope but it is a noose. Boys will be boys, as someone wrote,boys need to stay at home and play with toys, not ropes. I know blacks weren't the only people hung,who ever else that had ancestors hung need to speak up for them if they get a noose(rope) on their desk. This is not the first time in the Brazos Valley a noose has been put at a work place,I don't find it funny at all. How would people of the other race like a joke about their white grandfather going and getting babies by slave women, would they think that was a Joke?

Posted by: BIlly on Sep 3, 2008 at 08:33 PM
He planted it there so he could sue the company- Leech!

Posted by: M Location: Bryan on Sep 3, 2008 at 08:31 PM
"This is 2008, not '68, or '58, we've lived this in our teenage years." That's right. This is 2008. You are not in your teens anymore. The context from which this controversy is drawn is no longer valid to many people. Racism is not an everyday occurance for everyone like it once was. (I am not saying that it does not exist.) I vote in the "Blown out of proportion" column.

Posted by: Dan Location: College Station on Sep 3, 2008 at 08:23 PM
Was this really a noose or a rope. I would say this is more likly an weak attempt at early retirement. This man is playing on the symthathy of all Americans. He is also hoping the NAACP is hearing about this he has most likly called them himself by now. Just watch and see.

Posted by: Brenda Location: Caldwell on Sep 3, 2008 at 07:57 PM
If this rope was fashioned into a noose, it can only be seen as a threat. No matter the color of a person's skin or their ethnic heritage a noose represents death by hanging. It is in NO stretch of the imagination a joke that should be dismissed by anyone and I can only pray that the authorities investigate this with extreme diligence. There is no place in our community for ignorant jokes that threaten any individual or group of any color, ethnic background, or religion. If we accept such behavior as "boys will be boys," then we encourage hatred and violence against all. My prayers go out to all involved in this situation. May God grant wisdom, love, and peace to all concerned.

Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 3, 2008 at 07:28 PM
Look,this comment is for Chaka LaKeesha I work in the oilfield and if it wasn't for Halliburton, Caldwell would be smaller than Snook. So be thankful for what that MULTI BILLION DOLLAR COMPANY did for your town and if i am trailer park "Ta-rash" well then my $100,000 dollar a year salary must mean i qualify for welfare.

Posted by: Sick and Tired Location: This is BS! on Sep 3, 2008 at 07:20 PM
OMG! There are far worse things that people do to each other in this world regardless of race. Dry your eyes, wipe your nose and get over it!

Posted by: David Location: Texas on Sep 3, 2008 at 06:59 PM
This sounds like a big to do about nothing. I commend the employer for refusing to back down on this issue. Far too many caucasians are so in fear of being labeled a racist that they will slit their own throats in order to shed the label. This does not sound like a racial incident. I am Jewish. I don't cry foul when I rent a hotel room that has a shower. I don't say a word about a restaurant that has an oven in it. The next time I need a contractor I know exactly who I am going to. With little doubt some two bit, ambulance chasing lawyer is going to see this and jump at an opportunity to line his pockets at the expense of a legitimate business. It is time for lawsuit reform. I would encourage everyone in the community to band together and support this business. Who knows? Your place of business or mine might be the next to be victimized by something like this.

Posted by: L Location: Caldwell on Sep 3, 2008 at 06:20 PM
Racism hasn't gone very far according to many of the comments I have read. As a white person, I am horrified for this family and embarrassed for those of you who think this is a joke. I think Caldwell is a great place to live but its citizens and others in the Brazos Valley should be offended by this behavior.

Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 3, 2008 at 05:11 PM
I saw this on the news this morning, and if the are calling it "just a rope" I would have also mistaken it for a noose. Awful! I dont care if it was supposed to be a "joke" I dont take it as a joke, this is not funny! Nothing that has been used as a torture device to hurt or kill people should be used as a "joke" ...BAD TASTE! I pray that Mr. Eglan and his wife can get past this, and I also pray that the guilty party steps forward and receives their just punishment!

Posted by: student Location: CS on Sep 3, 2008 at 05:10 PM
I support freedom of speech as well: From these comments, we see the animals that reside in rural TX. Civilized people don't regard a noose as a joke, or even as "speech."

Posted by: Anonymous Location: orange tx on Sep 3, 2008 at 04:53 PM
Anonymous, brenham 3:34 why did they fire you, other than for being stupid??

Posted by: Woody Location: College Station on Sep 3, 2008 at 04:10 PM
Its a little offensive but not really a crime. If he didnt know the people and there was a nose there I would consider that a threat. But if he knew them well thats different. He should get them back by placing a kolache and a Brochure on double wide Trailers his desk. :-)

Posted by: Pastor Location: Bryan on Sep 3, 2008 at 04:09 PM
I just don't understand some people who choose to remain ignorant or in the dark about there are certain things you should not do. I don't care what kind of laugh you trying to get from your childlish games. You need to put yourself in that person place and ask yourself how would you feel if it was you and in if you have any doubt, ask... "What Will Jesus Do?"

Posted by: Anonymous Location: brenham on Sep 3, 2008 at 03:34 PM
one thing for sure is that is was put on this guys desk for a reason.if it was to retaliate against him for another employee being fired, it is condidered retaliation and that is a violation against eeoc as well as discrimation.it happens often here too.i hope this guy and his famiy push the issue and take this company to the cleaners.that is one way to open you racists eyes, take the mfs to the cleaners.God dont like ugly and he's not to fund of the pretty.should have contacted quanell x

Posted by: Elmer Location: CS on Sep 3, 2008 at 03:18 PM
How do you know it was a noose and not a twap for catching wabbits??

Posted by: diesel on Sep 3, 2008 at 03:00 PM
yep there were more people hung than just black people i am glad some people see that

Posted by: clint eastwood on Sep 3, 2008 at 02:46 PM
what exactly does this guy do for the company. He has desk? I think it `s his wife looking for hush money. Like I alway say Hang um High. If it goes to court it will end up a Hung jury.

Posted by: Whitey Location: Caldwell on Sep 3, 2008 at 02:43 PM
Let's face it, blacks will be blacks and whites will be whites. boys will be boys and girls will be girls. let's just accept the way things are and live together.

Posted by: cs res Location: cs on Sep 3, 2008 at 02:08 PM
um, perception is key here.

Posted by: Inthecorner Location: college station on Sep 3, 2008 at 02:06 PM
I will not comment on something I did not see for myself. One says a rope; one says a noose. I know, in my job I was accused of being prejudice and the lady that accused me had no clue what she was talking about. I am white and was very offended at the accusation merely because I helped a white customer! And this is not the only time she has said things involving race with other people and I have heard her use the word "honky". Nobody went to the press, an attorney or did she loose her job!

Posted by: john Location: cs on Sep 3, 2008 at 01:55 PM
maybe the citizens of the twin cities and surrounding area's should all boycott the kolache festival this year so our tax dollars won't support a racist city. i bet then the city counsil would get involved in the investigation and the real truth would come out. i don't think they care much about minorities until it hits the city in the pocketbooks.

Posted by: HaHa Location: BCS on Sep 3, 2008 at 01:45 PM
WOW! I am Mexican and a fence is offensive to me :P

Posted by: Terrie Location: Bryan on Sep 3, 2008 at 01:44 PM
So what was used hang my relatives? I notice that the only ones allowed to call it racism are black people. I have seen and heard many racist things from some black people. When people stop trying to wse things like this as a crutch or an excuse is when they will get ahead (no matter what their ethnicity is).

Posted by: agree with wow. on Sep 3, 2008 at 01:27 PM
Wow. I remember setting in on that case some as well. I can remember feeling such heartbreak for his family. I do not know how anyone would be able to play the race card after seeing what happened to that man. People are forgetting that we all have to meet our maker some day. Why can't we treat each other with dignity and respect.

Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 3, 2008 at 01:24 PM
Looking for MONEY.

Posted by: K Location: Caldwell on Sep 3, 2008 at 01:15 PM
I've known this company, it's managers and employees for over 6 years and let me tell you, it DOESN'T SURPRISE ME ONE BIT. I hope this gentleman takes it as far as it can go.

Posted by: Kolache Kid on Sep 3, 2008 at 12:52 PM
Hey, Ruth, don't be afraid of the kolache festival. Just stay away from the beer tent, that's where all the good ol' boys hang out. In all honesty, though, kolaches, jak se mas, and all that other stuff has really about run its course here in Caldwell.

Posted by: Rope hater on Sep 3, 2008 at 12:49 PM
Clearly rope needs to be outlawed. Rope is a symbol of racism. No decent person should have anything to do with rope. And while were at it let's also ban trees and horses because they were used to hang people too!

Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 3, 2008 at 12:46 PM
This man and his wife just want a fat retirement fund!

Posted by: get real Location: BCS on Sep 3, 2008 at 12:41 PM
So only black people were hung with a noose????? This is just someone trying to get some money, end of story!

Posted by: Real Deal on Sep 3, 2008 at 12:32 PM
This is just another example of PC run amok. It's a lot easier...and safer...to take the side of the idignant minority, whatever their perceived plight, than it is to speak the truth. Whites are victimized by blacks all the time, too. So, WTF,GET OVER IT.

Posted by: PC Location: Chicago on Sep 3, 2008 at 12:25 PM
Welcome to the new Politically Correct world, where everyone's intolerance must be respected. The noose, used to hang thousands of people of all races is now a symbol of racial hatred against blacks. Why, because they say it is. If you had a noose on your desk, why was it untied at the time of the news report? You felt discriminated against and your first thought was to destroy the evidence? If there was a "noose" left on his desk and he found it, why were we shown a rope and asked to believe it had been tied in a noose? My final question is what kind of knots are considered racism by other races? I don't want to accidentally leave a half-hitch near and Asian person should they find that offensive.

Posted by: DC Location: Bryan on Sep 3, 2008 at 12:19 PM
Since when is a noose racist? I dare to say that more white criminals were hung than innocent blacks. Racism is alive and well because a few people refuse to let go of the issue.

Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 3, 2008 at 12:06 PM
Just out for money....move on...next story

Posted by: Aggie Location: B/CS on Sep 3, 2008 at 12:04 PM
The beauty of Free Speech is that even idiots and bigots get to do it. Post away my moronic minions.

Posted by: Cop1 Location: College Station on Sep 3, 2008 at 11:19 AM
How about Halloween,have you ever seen a dummy,or a figure hanging from a tree? Is that racial? Not until a black family hangs a white figure or a white family hangs a black figure. Was this incident directed at a black man or just a man? However, it is a bad joke. What ever caused this incident will probably never surface.I hope it was only a bad joke and not a racial demonstration. Black panthers!! Talk about racial.

Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 3, 2008 at 11:04 AM
how is this racist? so do they think that no white man was ever hung?

Posted by: Wow. Location: Stupid on Sep 3, 2008 at 11:03 AM
I worked on the Jasper dragging case when it was here in Brazos County and I will tell you, if they had posted pics of what happen to that poor man there would not be a single racist left in this world.

Posted by: Angry Location: College Station on Sep 3, 2008 at 10:58 AM
It looks like a rope not a noose. I think that it is getting out of hand and perhaps it is Joseph and Linda who have a problem with race. People are always hurting other people with distasteful comments or actions and most of the time it wasn't meant to be hurtful. Is it because the are black that this should be considered racial. Maybe it's just a case of poor judgement.

Posted by: Anonymous Location: BC on Sep 3, 2008 at 10:54 AM
This story is blown way out of context. Im employed with Big Creek and I have known about this for weeks. First of all the rope was used by another employee to tie something on his truck. It was a slip knot not a noose. When it was removed from the truck the rope was thrown back in the shop on the shop foreman's desk. Not Joseph desk. He doesn't even have a desk or a office. This is in retaliation for another employee getting fired for insubordination. Its all a big crock in a try to get rich scheme. I saw this so called "noose" and to me it looked just like a rope tied in a knot. Nothing racial about it. Hopefully management can convince him it was not racial in any way.

Posted by: Ridiculous Location: Bryan on Sep 3, 2008 at 10:40 AM
They say this was just a joke but we all know what kind of joke it was....a racist one. This conduct would NEVER be tolerated in my workplace. I take it this company/managers have never been given a class on ethics! This class should be mandatory for all companies! BTW I am white and totally understand Mr. Eglan’s complaint! Obviously the jokes going on at this work place probably should have been addressed b4 now!

Posted by: Mongo Location: Aridzona on Sep 3, 2008 at 10:38 AM
You would not believe how ridiculously black people act about a hangmans noose. At a place I one worked I was idly playing with some string (STRING) and tied it into a noose. This black guy who was nearby "freaked out" claiming that because it had 13 loops it was considered a deadly weapon and I could go to jail for making it (remember we are talking about string here). He also started b!tching that I was being racist. I wasn't being "racist" I just was messing around with some string. H3ll it never occurred to me that a noose had anything to do with racism. So I chased him around the room with it. Get over it! One cannot go around worry about offending everyone. If your offended by something that's your problem, NOT MINE!

Posted by: LET'S BE SERIOUS.. Location: BRYAN on Sep 3, 2008 at 10:36 AM
OMG...LET'S BE SERIOUS...THIS IS 2008 & YES WE DO STILL HAVE SOME PEOPLE THAT ARE IGNORANT..I DON'T SEE HOW ANYONE CAN SAY THAT THIS IS NOT OFFENSIVE. IF YOU KNOW THE HISTORY ABOUT BLACK HERITAGE THEN YOU WOULD KNOW WHY THIS NOOSE(NOT ROPE) WAS SO OFFENSIVE. THEY USED THESE NOOSES TO HANG BLACK PEOPLE WITH FOR NO REASON. THE NOOSE ITSELF SYMBOLIZES NEGATIVE & CRUEL THINGS THAT HAPPENED IN HISTORY TO BLACK PEOPLE THAT SHOULD'VE NEVER HAPPEN. FOR HIM BEING AN OLDER BLACK MAN IT WAS JUST A LITTLE TOO CLOSE TO HOME. I AM A BLACK WELL EDUCATED FEMALE WHO DOESN'T USE THE RACE CARD THROUGHOUT LIFE BUT SOMEHOW IT IS STILL A FACTOR IN TODAYS SOCIETY WHY I DON'T KNOW BECAUSE WE ARE ALL EQUAL. I WILL AGREE SOME BLACK PEOPLE WILL TRY TO USE THE RACE CARD TO GET SYMPATHY BUT TO THEM I SAY GET OVER IT.

Posted by: Bryan on Sep 3, 2008 at 10:30 AM
First of all, if the person put this on his desk then he was trying to be funny. He just went a little too far. He should be terminated. I hope Justice is done!!!

Posted by: RUTH Location: COLLEGE STATION on Sep 3, 2008 at 10:28 AM
I WAS PLANNING TO GO TO THE KOLACHE FESTIVAL IN CALDWELL BUT NOW I AM SCARED TO GO. EVERY EMPLOYEE AT THIS COMPANY NEEDS A POLYYGRAPH EXAM TO SEE WHO DID THIS. THEY SHOULD BE FIRED ALONG WITH THE "BOSS".

Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 3, 2008 at 10:19 AM
hey everyone that complains about something is not out looking for money. he might have plenty of money and if he feels that someone was making racial comments or racial jokes in the work place then he needed to speak out. me personally if someone was to do it to me i would do it to and wouldn't think twice about it.

Posted by: Goldberg Location: BCS on Sep 3, 2008 at 10:15 AM
Finding a noose on my desk would make me mad too, but the first thing I would do is asked all the smart-as--d co-workers who put it there, not call a lawyer, naacp, aclu and my wife! Looking for a LAWSUIT! Get over it Dude, we ALL get insulted in this RUDE, NO MANNERS world! Find out who made the noose and left it on your desk and confront him if he is man enough. If he won't come forward, let the owners of the company know he has at least ONE COWARD working for him! You went crying to your WIFE??????? JEEEEESH!

Posted by: wow, just wow. Location: bryan on Sep 3, 2008 at 10:12 AM
I guess I'm just a slow learner, but I am amazed every time I see a person that actively seeks something to be upset about. They will always find it. It's a piece of rope with a knot in it. I bet every one of of us including these folks complaining have one in their garage too. A year or two ago on the A&M campus a similar stink took place over a rope contractors were using to hoist buckets up to the roof of a dorm they were working on. It's a knotted rope people. The Boy Scouts teach knot tying, according to this ridiculous logic the Boy Scouts are racist because they tie knots in rope too. Wow. Just wow...

Posted by: give me a break on Sep 3, 2008 at 10:08 AM
you have aired this story more than it ever needed to be! give me a break!!!!! you are taking one mans opinion on if it was a noose. why is this story even on the news. do we not have anything else better to report?? im sure this stuff happens everyday, to people of all colors!!!!!!

Posted by: stan Location: austin on Sep 3, 2008 at 10:06 AM
I lived in Caldwell for over 20 yrs. and there is no doubt that it is for the most part a very racist town. From school admins. to business owners and civic leaders. I am a white man that hopes Mr. Eglan gets the respect he deserves, while also being able to provide for himself and his family.

Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 3, 2008 at 10:03 AM
shame on those people for their ignorance.....shame on this company who is wiping it under the table......get a lawyer and sue the heck out of them for not taking this serious and as an insult to anyone no matter what color their skin is.....

Posted by: Alex Location: Bryan on Sep 3, 2008 at 10:02 AM
Let's see - every other time I know of an incident like this it has happened to be the "target" that actually did it! Remember the case most recently of that Baltimore Fireman that did this because he was incompetent? "Donald Maynard"

Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 3, 2008 at 09:49 AM
If he was so concerned, why did his WIFE contact management and not him??? Why was she even on the news...this has nothing to do wtih her, but an incident between him and his employer...keep the wife out of it.

Posted by: BT on Sep 3, 2008 at 09:46 AM
Why is it always a noose, and then its called racist, hello, we African Americans weren't the only ones strung up from trees in the days of old but now every time something comes up it's racist. Makes the whole community look bad, like the boy who cried wolf

Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 3, 2008 at 09:45 AM
I've heard it didn't even resemble a noose. It was just a 5 inch piece of rope someone left laying on a work table...a nooses is a noose...a piece of rope is JUST a piece of rope...move on, next story...

Posted by: Tori on Sep 3, 2008 at 09:24 AM
All I want to know is why did he wait 2 weeks to do anything about it. And, if it was indeed a noose, why isn't it still in the shape of a noose instead of a straight piece of rope with a slipknot??? You would think that if you were going to report something of this nature, you would want to keep the evidence in place.

Posted by: Grace on Sep 3, 2008 at 09:23 AM
So now a noose is automatically anti-African American? Were African American's the only one who were ever hung? I think not. I'm sorry if they were offended but dang there is no proof it was directed against African Americans.

Posted by: M Location: Bryan on Sep 3, 2008 at 09:13 AM
Until everyone, Blacks, whites, brown, or purple stop using race as an issue it will always be an issue. If you think a certain race is making you feel beneath them, then rise up. You can not change how a single person will react or act in a situation, you can only change how you react/act in a situation. Change starts at home.

Posted by: DARRELL Location: TENNESSEE on Sep 3, 2008 at 09:09 AM
Just give him about hundred thousand dollars thats all he wants.

Posted by: ginny Location: cove on Sep 3, 2008 at 09:06 AM
jennifer i think YOU sound very racist.in fact anyone that would vote for someone just because of the color of their skin or because of their sex is a very very sick puppy.we have no one running worth voting for period. the people in our goverment are out to take care of themselves they really don't give a rats behind about the rest of it. and why is it there can be a NAACP and black panthers but if these is something just for whites only that is NOT allowed because it's racist? hello someone answer that one for me.just EVERYONE stop being so racist and become AMERICAN

Posted by: Aggie12 Location: Walton Hall on Sep 3, 2008 at 09:02 AM
Hey Patriot and all the others who think this is just a joke and no big deal, you are showing your ignorance. Maybe to you it is a joke, but the joke was not played on you, it was played on this man and he did not find it funny. So what a black man is running for president. That does not mean that there is not still a lot of racist people out there. Since you bring up the election, if you watched the news you would see that the black candidate that you mentioned has received more death threats than any candidate according to the Secret Service Department. But I guess according to you "they were just joking" when some of these who have threaten the black candidate were arrested with bullet proof vest, a number of automatic weapons, and ammo? Yeah, you are right they were just joking. I better let you go wash your "sheets" now.

Posted by: ginny Location: cove on Sep 3, 2008 at 08:59 AM
ya know back in the day lots of people were hanged. like cattle rustlers and murderers witches were burned at the stake. it was wrong all of the bad things that happened. people get over the past!! get on with YOUR life you did not get hung!!. let's concentrate on now!! all the child murders and abuse that's what you should ALL be concerned with. and by the way STOP calling yourselves AFRICAN-AMERICAN. you are AMERICANS. if you can't accept that then move to Africa. same with MEXICAN-AMERICAN and ASIAN-AMERICAN. drop the prefix and join AMERICA!!!!

Posted by: Suvior Location: Bryan on Sep 3, 2008 at 08:59 AM
I know the victim and I can truly say he is not looking for media attention but he brought this to light because hidden racism still exsist, even close to twin cities with a major University in our backyards. I don't care what ethnicity you are...no one in their work place should have to tolerate it and jokes of that nature is not acceptable.

Posted by: reshell Location: college station on Sep 3, 2008 at 08:52 AM
racism does exist in these back yard towns and people dont realize that racism is racism no matter who it is done to. yau asy we have complained for a long tome about being mistreaded but look at the people in japan,during the time of the holycaust,they were at least given an appoligy. even the indians were compensated for being treated the way they were the blacks were not even given there mule and 40 acres even the foreign people are compensated financially.WHERE IS OUR LAND. i could surely use mine,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

Posted by: JKO Location: Bryan on Sep 3, 2008 at 08:51 AM
I just hate seeing things like this. Black America needs to Stop looking for hand outs and trying to make something out of nothing. I am fed up with Blacks thinking America owes them something. I mean come on the majority of them are already taking advantage of the system. Sounds like this guy is just like all the rest looking for some extra cash. What ashame

Posted by: Jon Location: England on Sep 3, 2008 at 08:48 AM
Seems like a case of blatant racism to me. Love & Mercy.

Posted by: Anonymous Location: Bryan on Sep 3, 2008 at 08:45 AM
Horseplay is horseplay but there comes a point where you can cross the line. It is not funny to leave a noose on a desk. I am too young to be able to say that I lived through the civil rights movement but looking at the faces of this man and his wife, I felt so bad for them. The were obviously offended and an apology is definitely in order here at the very least. Acts like this in the workplace should never be tolerated.

Posted by: john Location: saint louis on Sep 3, 2008 at 08:44 AM
wow, i guess he figured out how to get his money now,everyone looking for away to get paid, a rope is not a noose, and if you heard the story he refused to cooperate with the company/

Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 3, 2008 at 08:41 AM
Maybe he put it there himself- get some attention or better yet maybe some easy money. Regardless, BIG DEAL. I am SICK and TIRED of all of the cry babies out there. It's a stupid rope tied into a knot. GET OVER IT!

Posted by: Hispanic Location: Bryan on Sep 3, 2008 at 08:31 AM
I don't agree with what happened, and I think it should be looked in very closely, but most African American people do act like we owe them something. Every race has had their own fair share of hatefulness, and still to this day.....

Posted by: Confused Location: Bryan on Sep 3, 2008 at 08:24 AM
I'm sorry; I didn't realize that blacks were the only race in history to be hung by a noose. Seriously, I don’t see what specifically about a noose is racial. Should a noose have been put on anyone’s desk? No. I have Native American heritage, and believe me there were as many Native Americans hung by a rope as blacks. I just don’t see where the racism charge is coming from. Sure the action was inappropriate, but racist? I don’t think so.

Posted by: Caldwellian on Sep 3, 2008 at 08:17 AM
Now listen here, KBTX, we got ourselves an IMAGE to maintain here in Caldwell, and you you people ain't helping us one bit.

Posted by: Elizabeth Location: Caldwell on Sep 3, 2008 at 08:03 AM
Why would someone just put a rope on his desk? Everybody knows deep down that it was intended to look like a noose. What would be the joke of just a rope?? Caldwell is full of prejudice people, and even if this was just a practical joke, it's not funny. How would some of his coworkers feel if he put a black inner tube on one of their desks...but its just a tube, not a way of transportation across the border... I don't think so. Racism should not be tolerated in the workplace.

Posted by: DaVE Location: NC on Sep 3, 2008 at 07:32 AM
Hmmm. I guess black people were the only people ever hanged in this country. They seem to want to "own" the noose for their own personal "pain".

Posted by: We All Came From Somewhere Else Location: Burleson County on Sep 3, 2008 at 07:24 AM
My family is Irish, but I don't complain that Caldwell Brookshire Brothers sells potatoes, or that the Caldwell liquor stores sell whiskey, or that there is a 'Dirty Nellys Irish Pub' in San Antonio (Mexican-settled city). From this Irish to you, there ain't no free pot of gold at the end of no rainbow. Blacks call each other the "n-word" ALL THE TIME just listen to black teens thinking they are cute. Blacks also call white people and Mexican-Americans names, too. Blacks are just a prejudiced as whites and Mexican-Americans so why are they always 'victims'?. I am sick of it all the way around no matter what color starts what. We all came from somewhere else, so why can't we just get along with respect. And because some one offends you, how you react and respond in print is equally as important in what it says about YOU.

Posted by: Katrina C Location: Wellborn on Sep 3, 2008 at 07:24 AM
Even without it being a racist situation, the history of the noose has been death. Not funny no matter who it is in my eyes. Racist, could be, but hanging was a punishment used on ALL RACES back even before the United States were colonies. Sick and completely NOT FUNNY, yes, racist, I can't comment on because I'm not the idiots who thought it would be funny. Even if this wasn't racist, it's still what anyone else would probably think of, as a threat on their lives. I mean, a noose sure wasn't something that kids played with and swung on back in the ole' days, it was for killers, traitors and thieves, and then later on used for punishment of slaves. SO DEFINITELY NOT FUNNY

Posted by: bills Location: bcs on Sep 3, 2008 at 06:38 AM
If it was just a rope on his desk, then where is the joke? Thats not funny. Most people would walk up and just move the rope, and wonder what its doing there? How can a piece of rope be a joke? Now i could see how a few racist idiots would think a noose is funny. Yes i think it was a noose! How can any one say, "we just put a rope on his desk, its gonna be funny" I just dont get how a rope could be a joke. A noose is the most logic answer and its not funny.

Posted by: J Location: CS on Sep 3, 2008 at 12:54 AM
This is ridiculous. It is like everyone is looking for something for them to be offended by. This is not racist it is just an incident that apparently happened and was blown out of proportion.

Posted by: R Location: CS on Sep 2, 2008 at 11:14 PM
Whether it was done as a prejudiced or not prejudiced joke, if it was in fact, a noose, it should not be tolerated in any workplace under any circumstances. I think further investigation is required into this situation; perhaps it was a joke taken too far, but if not a joke, then some repercussions should be made as no one should ever be made to feel in harm's way in the workplace.

Posted by: Freedom of Speech Location: Caldwell on Sep 2, 2008 at 11:03 PM
So with this news article, does that me you can no longer use the phrase " give them enough rope and they will eventually hang themselves." A rope is a rope, it just had a few twists and a knot in it. But it is still a rope.

Posted by: laura Location: iola on Sep 2, 2008 at 10:50 PM
for the comment earlier about caldwell a great place to live what a joke,caldwell is full rascim of all kinds black white, poor rich plus if you want to find drugs or catch something that where to go. why do you think alot of the kids are home school.

Posted by: Saddened Location: College Station on Sep 2, 2008 at 10:30 PM
Everyone knows that the noose has bad connotations, some of them racial. Saying you don't understand what makes it racial is being deliberately obtuse, and won't change reality. Some people are able to ignore it and move on. Others have wounds too deep and can't just shrug it off. Someone at the receiving end of this "joke" might not be immediately offended, but would surely at least wonder if there was a message being conveyed below the surface of the "joke". These things just have too much controversy attached to them and should simply be avoided, period.

Posted by: Jennifer Location: Bryan on Sep 2, 2008 at 10:25 PM
You people must think blacks are crazy, This is sad! what in the world is wrong with you, how would you feel "WHITE AMERICA", if you came to work with a White KKK hood on your desk? Would you think it was a great big joke? Well guess what, I hope this company gets what it needs a great big kick in the fannie by the NAACP. Black Families Are sick of whites, and any other race thinking blacks are in a lower postitin than they are. This as to do with the fact that a half black man is running to be THE leader of what you may think is your WHITE America, well the slave days are soon to be over. Where are the black panthers when we need them?

Posted by: Howell Location: Somerville on Sep 2, 2008 at 10:19 PM
I know this dude that is the "victim". He said to a friend of mine that he was going to get a lot of attention some day. Maybe that's what he meant.

Posted by: Samantha Location: Bryan on Sep 2, 2008 at 10:03 PM
Wow! I have read some of the comments below and I am sick! I know several people from Caldwell; they are some of the worst racists I know and I refuse to be around them! I knew racism was rampant in this part of the Country, but seriously people, wake up! You are hidious and horrible!

Posted by: Anonymous Location: Hearne on Sep 2, 2008 at 10:02 PM
Sounds like someone is looking for money.

Posted by: Chaka LaKeesha Location: Caldwell on Sep 2, 2008 at 09:55 PM
Ever since Halliburton brought its disgusting trash with it to town in the early 80's, Caldwell has slowly deteriorated into scuzzy trailer park ta-rash! To live there is to believe it.

Posted by: Been over it Location: around the corner on Sep 2, 2008 at 09:51 PM
The comment is to the hitler wanna be "Get over it". We live in a crazy world where racism will always be around. If a person feel a offended thats him but be responsible what you state, your posted statement alone is a bigot remark, give me the shovel i dig him up and place on your door step, but dont get offended i would just be a grave robber. Some people are so blind they dont want to admitt there will always be racism. You are right it is a rope. Personally I wouldnt have went that far with the news, I would have handled it the Old fashion way Whoop somebody. You dont know what this man been though he probably been chased down, or beaten, or even death threats in his younger years, so if you dont have a r