CS's Red Light Cameras to Stay On; Restraining Order Issued
Save Email Print
Updated: 9:29 PM Nov 11, 2009
CS's Red Light Cameras to Stay On; Restraining Order Issued
A temporary restraining order has been issued preventing the City of College Station from shutting down its red light camera program.
Posted: 10:55 AM Nov 11, 2009
Reporter: Steve Fullhart and Karla Castillo
Email Address: fullhart@kbtx.com, castillo@kbtx.com
Font Size:

Wednesday morning, a visiting judge granted the order following a filing from a pair of program supporters. The city was due to turn off its cameras by noon Wednesday.

Earlier in the day, the city council canvassed the votes from the November 3 election, one which saw 52 percent of voters choose to end the city's program.

The citizens who filed for the order claim the election should not have taken place in the first place due to language in the charter.

"My concern is when we have the election and if we vote to remove red light cameras from the community then American Traffic Solutions or anyone else would have the door open to file a lawsuit saying that the city of College Station referred to it many times as a referendum. And that would un-do the election," Jim Ash told News Three in August.

Prophetic words from the man who helped bring the red light camera vote to College Station. It was just over a week ago that he and fellow red light camera opponents were celebrating after residents voted to end the program.

"It's our contention that the election is invalid," said Roger Gordon.

Gordon represents John Hemrick and Gary Ives, the two College Station residents who filed suit against the city. They contend that Ash's petition was a referendum to repeal an existing law, rather than an initiative to create a new ordinance.

"Under the city charter you've got 20 days after an ordinance is passed to bring this matter to your city council and get it before the voters," said Gordon.

According to Gordon, the petition to put the red light camera issue on the ballot was submitted 609 days after the deadline.

At Wednesday's hearing the visiting judge asked city representatives if they thought the red light camera petition was a referendum or an initiative.

College Station Attorney Harvey Cargill said "We are on the record as questioning what this is." He added they're looking to the court to make the decision.

The hearing is set for Friday, November 20th at 1 p.m.

If the judge determines the red light camera petition was a referendum, the election results will be overturned. If she rules it was an initiative, the results will stand and the red light cameras will come down.

The following is a statement from College Station City Manager, Glenn Brown.

"We respect Judge Stovall’s decision to grant the plaintiffs’ request for a temporary restraining order and will look to her for a decision about the validity of the Nov. 3 election results."

"However, should the judge rule that the election is invalid and that the red-light cameras should stay, I will recommend to the College Station City Council that we immediately inform American Traffic Solutions that we are giving them the required 60-day notice that we are canceling our contract and the cameras will be turned off."


Latest Comments

Posted by: Gary Location: Oregon on Nov 27, 2009 at 09:50 PM

Glad to see my friends in Texas are taking these thieves on like we are up here. Lets face it, like everything else government does, the stated purpose (which is usually benevolent sounding – i.e. reduce traffic injuries) is almost never the real motivation behind a “program”. Lowered speed limits in the name of safety are just a way of producing revenue by creating a ridiculous low limit that is unrealistic and difficult to maintain – the speed trap. These cameras are nothing more than that, a revenue producing device. In some places the even sink as low as shortening yellow light times to trick drivers into running a red…low. The best way to keep their thieving hands out of your pocket is to know where the cameras are an avoid them. The simplest way is to use your GPS unit with data you can get at a site like http://www.gpscameradetector.com.
Posted by: Anonymous on Nov 13, 2009 at 07:56 AM

...and KBTX tries to make Robertson County sound screwed up. This reminds me of Florida in the Bush election days.
Posted by: LiveFreeOrDie on Nov 12, 2009 at 11:33 PM

This issue has moved beyond whether or not a few people still like red light cameras. Public opinion of the cameras was settled in an official city election. The issue has moved beyond safety as well. The Keep College Station Safe commercial proved that a bus accident still takes place when there is a camera watching. A more appropriate question is "Are we still a government by the people and for the people?" Either this council can listen to the people or we will gladly replace them, starting with the mayor and councilman Massey in May.
AP Video
Community Media
    College Station Now
    Bryan's Living and Learning