News 3 Now ·  Desktop WX ·  Contact ·  Site Map
Home  ·   News  ·   Weather  ·   Sports  ·   Features  ·   Business  ·   Morning Show  ·   The Buzz  ·   Eye on You (Your Photos & Videos)  ·   KBTX Cares  ·   Green
Top Stories · National · State · Local · Business · Entertainment · Texas A&M News · College News · BCSPolitics.com · Trans-Texas Corridor News
Missing Oil Well Royalties Have A Normangee Family Asking Questions Save Email Print
Posted: 11:10 PM Aug 27, 2008
Last Updated: 11:10 PM Aug 27, 2008
Reporter: Wendell Edwards
Email Address: news@kbtx.com

A | A | A

Deep in the heart of Southeast Texas, oil wells are hard at work, earning people money. Erma Hall’s oil well pumps and churns near Caldwell in Burleson County. It’s run by Mineral Technologies out of Midland, but the land it sits on belongs to Hall, who is 99 years old. She lives on a street that bears her last name in the town of Normagee, about 40 miles from her oil well. The oil-rich land has been in Hall’s family for some time. In fact, her mother’s name, Amelia Whitfield Washington, is on the lease agreement. It’s up to folks like Lee Perry to make sure heirs like Hall get their oil royalty payments. But Hall hasn’t received any money at all.

“Well, the oil company at the time said they didn’t know how to find the relatives of Amelia Whitfield Washington, which is … that’s her mother,” Perry said. “Oil companies, all they have to say is, ‘we don’t know who to pay it to,’ and that’s it.”

Hall’s relatives didn’t even know they were entitled to any money at all – that is, until they started asking questions. Then they filed a lawsuit against the oil company and began fighting for royalties.
It’s money they say rightfully belongs to their mother.

“It’s like stealing. Oh gracious, any way you put it, it is theft,” Hall’s oldest daughter, Hilda Hall Harrell, said.

Perry said Hall’s well has been a moneymaker ever since drilling started in 1997, earning as much as $20 million. That means Hall’s family should get around $2.4 million. And it turns out Mineral Technologies is not alone. At least three other oil companies have used the same well, and not one of them has ever paid an heir to the land one dime. But that’s where the story gets complicated. In a way, the problem is that Erma Hall came from a big family. Even Mineral Technologies agrees Hall is a rightful heir, but she’s not the only one.

“The current heirs may total more than 40 different individuals of which Ms. Hall allegedly may own as little as 3/84 of the estate’s interest or less. There is, however, disagreement among the heirs that has made it necessary for MTI to turn over the proceeds to the court while the heirs resolve their differences,” the company’s president told 11 News in an e-mail.

Since the lawsuit, the company has put $75,000 in the court registry, and it contributes more money every month. The money will stay there until all the heirs are found.

“There are some other heirs – nephews and nieces – find those and try to get this thing resolved. But that was in December. Here we are in August, and it still hasn’t been done. She still hasn’t gotten one red cent,” Perry said of Hall.

And it seems Hall may have to wait even longer for her little piece of an oil fortune.

More Stories
Second Man Pleads Guilty In Pot-Smoking-Toddlers Case

11 Hurt When Car Plows In Crowd At Texas Parade

Police Officer Hit By Patrol Car Dies

Texas Woman Found Clinging To Life Alone In House

Texas Teen Will Bullet In Head Accepts Plea Deal

Car Plows Into Parade Crowd in East Texas; Several Injured

Former First Lady In Good Condition

Supreme Court Refuses Appeals Of Two Death Row Inmates

Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
Email will not be displayed on site. For station contact purpose only.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: Anesha Location: Roberton County on Aug 29, 2008 at 11:39 PM
How can you get in contact with Mr. Lee Perry?

Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 29, 2008 at 02:33 PM
Hey "theDoctor"...your blogs suck!!

Posted by: hwa Location: bryan on Aug 29, 2008 at 10:29 AM
THE DOCTOR IS RIGHT IN MY OPINION, SOMEONE HAD TO SIGN THE LEASE AND THAT SOMEONE HAD TO KNOW THAT HE OR SHE WASN"T THE ONLY PERSON THAT HAD INTEREST IN THE PROPERTY. FIND THAT PERSON AND THE PROBLEM WILL BE EASY TO SOLVE.I PERSONALLY KNOW MRS HALL AND HATE TO SEE HER GET CHEATED OUT OF WHAT IS RIGHTFULLY HERS...

Posted by: theDoctor Location: Bryan on Aug 29, 2008 at 08:19 AM
Kim, your best option is to get a lawyer, nevertheless, you can do a title search with the county records and file a motion against the company yourself but that will take some time on your part. That why lawyer are good in situation like this because they can file this motion quicker. That is why I stated that they could have found this woman if they wanted, becuase they have to do a title search on the land and establish all owners before they can even start drilling. That is the law.

Posted by: Do it right and there's no fight Location: Burleson County on Aug 29, 2008 at 07:08 AM
Many people don't establish Wills, and many families don't probate a Will or settle an estate. It happens all the time, and the rest of the world shouldn't have to stop and cleanup the messes left by these irresponsible knuckleheads. You can't just "say" who owns what...and then accuse others for not knowing your unrecorded family legacy. All those unrecorded owners don't pony up to pay the property taxes either, but they sure know how to hold out their hand when they think it's payday!

Posted by: Kim Location: Caldwell on Aug 28, 2008 at 07:13 PM
My family is the rightful owners of some oil and mineral rights purchased by my grandfather. Several years ago, some people showed up at my mother's door with a royalty check, and then tried to recant saying that it didn't belong to us. My mother, aunt, and great aunt had an oil attorney looking into it and the attorney found out that the records at the courthouse had been tampered with and my grandfather's first initial, which was a "C" had been typed over and changed to an "O". However, my family didn't have the money to pursue the issue any further, and everyone involved in that has since passed away. None of us know where any of the documentation went. We would really like to find out where to go with this to find out the pertinent information to pursue this. Is there anyone that can help??

Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 28, 2008 at 03:50 PM
Sounds like time for a family reunion to me.

Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 28, 2008 at 10:21 AM
Hmmmm, my family is Hall - some of whom lived in Normangee, Texas

Posted by: theDoctor Location: Bryan on Aug 28, 2008 at 09:58 AM
Yes, it maybe up to the families to update information, nevertheless, I am sure the oil companies did not try as hard to find them as they did when they found the person to lease the land from. They could have found her if they wanted, simple as that.

Posted by: bj Location: navasota on Aug 28, 2008 at 09:56 AM
i no of a simalar incident where this happened and approx fifty years later not a dime.

Posted by: Anon on Aug 28, 2008 at 09:48 AM
question is who do they owe, bring them on and they will pay. who is going to spend the money sourcing long lost relatives. how many have passed and left aires. the lawyer wins if anybody.

Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 28, 2008 at 08:05 AM
"Since the lawsuit, the company has put $75,000 in the court registry, and it contributes more money every month. The money will stay there until all the heirs are found." Errrr, shouldn't they pony up the full 2.4 Million that they KNEW they owed SOMEBODY???

Posted by: LW Location: Bryan on Aug 28, 2008 at 08:00 AM
When a well is permitted by the Railroad Commission, they look to see if the complete unit of acreage is under lease by the drilling operator. Any heir problems results in the acreage portion of that lease being put into a trust account until the heirs work out who's share is what. The problems are frequent in areas where people don't bring the records up to date in a timely way after a death of a family member.

Posted by: Misunderstanding Location: Bryan on Aug 28, 2008 at 07:17 AM
The oil company signed the lease with the current owner of the land/minerals. The current owner accepted all royalties and negleted to share the profits with the rest of the family or notify the oil company of the other heirs. This can easily happen because the other family members are not on record for that piece of land at the county courthouse. This way, the oil company has no idea of all the other relatives that deserve money. Sounds like the family needs to be going after the person who signed the lease with the oil company.

AP Video
Digital TV